Without an effective backlog grooming process, teams risk a backlog susceptible to disorganization, resulting in decreased collaboration and project delays. Learning how to run practical backlog grooming sessions can lead to more productive engagements and help keep your team aligned, ensuring that valuable time is spent on work that truly matters. This practice is fundamental to Agile methodologies, acting as a proactive measure to maintain order, clarity, and focus within product development cycles.

This article will provide a comprehensive guide to understanding and implementing effective backlog grooming. This post will cover:

• What is backlog grooming?
• Who owns the backlog grooming process.
• Backlog refinement best practices.
• Workfront: A solution for effective backlog grooming.

What is backlog grooming?

Backlog grooming, also known as backlog refinement, is a session in which project managers and other stakeholders communicate, analyze, and prioritize backlog items. Commonly referred to as backlog refinement, or backlog management, backlog grooming aims to keep the backlog up to date and ensure that items are ready for impending sprints.

Backlog refinement meetings offer a chance for a cross-functional team to review the progress of products in development. When done effectively and on the right cadence, these sessions can help prevent the backlog from growing into an overwhelming amount of content.

The goal of backlog grooming.

The primary goals of backlog grooming are to review outstanding user stories in the backlog, verify that they're correctly prioritized, and ensure they’re ready for sprint preparations. At the end of the session, you should have an organized and prioritized list of user stories.

Many agile practitioners say that a DEEP product backlog is the key outcome of a backlog refinement session. The DEEP acronym highlights some critical traits associated with the product backlog:

• Detailed appropriately. Stories and other backlog items should contain enough contextual information to be understood and discussed by the cross-functional team.
• Emergent. Adding new items and stories should be simple as new information becomes available, so nothing is finalized.
• Estimated. The effort required for each user story should be estimated through a measurement that’s agreed upon by the team.
• Prioritized. Items in the backlog should be ranked depending on their tactical purpose and the value they provide.
  
  The DEEP product backlog acronym can be a good way to keep your team on track, but it’s up to your organization to determine what processes work best for your team.

Benefits of backlog grooming.

Consistent and effective backlog refinement provides numerous benefits that ripple throughout the Agile team and the broader organization, significantly impacting project outcomes and overall productivity. These advantages range from enhanced operational efficiency to improved team dynamics and product quality.

Here are several ways your team can benefit from backlog grooming:

• Improved sprint planning: A well-refined backlog is the bedrock of effective sprint planning. When items are already clarified, estimated, and prioritized, sprint planning meetings become shorter, more focused, and more productive. The team can concentrate on delivering the work rather than spending excessive time trying to understand what it is.
• Increased work velocity: By ensuring tasks are clearly defined and appropriately sized, refinement reduces ambiguity and the likelihood of rework. This streamlining of workflows means less wasted time and resources, enabling the team to deliver value more consistently and sustainably.
• Reduced waste: Unnecessary tasks or features that don't align with current business outcomes can be identified and removed during refinement, preventing wasted effort on low-value activities.
• Enhanced team collaboration: Backlog refinement is inherently a collaborative activity, fostering communication and shared ownership among the Product Owner, development team, and other stakeholders. This strengthens team cohesion and ensures everyone is working towards the same objectives.
• Transparency: The process ensures that everyone involved in the project is aware of the status of different items and upcoming priorities, leading to fewer interruptions and more productive work.
• Improved risk management: Refinement sessions provide an opportunity to identify potential roadblocks, dependencies between items, and technical complexities early in the process. Addressing these issues proactively minimizes surprises and delays during sprints.
• Improved client or customer satisfaction: By aligning development efforts with clearly understood customer needs and continuously refining the product based on feedback, teams are more likely to deliver products that meet or exceed customer expectations, thereby improving overall product quality and satisfaction. Consistent refinement ensures alignment with the product roadmap and contributes to the long-term quality of the product.

Collectively, these benefits directly contribute to a more agile and responsive organization. This, in turn, can lead to a faster time-to-market for valuable features, providing a significant competitive advantage in today's fast-paced business environment. Thus, backlog refinement is not merely an internal operational improvement; it's a strategic enabler for achieving broader business objectives.

Who owns the backlog grooming process.

The product owner or product manager should own the backlog grooming process — but they may not solely be responsible for hosting backlog grooming sessions, depending on the hierarchical structure of your organization. The Scrum Master, a project manager, or a different team member could also lead these sessions.

An even more important component of the process is ensuring your designated team members have the skills necessary to manage backlog grooming. The designated person's conduct during the sessions will determine the future productivity and success of the projects. You can experiment with different roles before deciding who’s the best fit to lead the refinement session.

Regardless of who facilitates explicitly, the core responsibilities associated with owning and running the backlog refinement process include:

• Scheduling: Organizing the session at an appropriate frequency and ensuring all necessary participants are invited and can attend.

• Agenda preparation: Create a clear agenda for the session and share it with attendees in advance to allow for preparation.

• Guiding discussions: Leading the team through the selected backlog items, with the Product Owner providing explanations, context, and answering business-related questions.

• Maintaining focus: Keeping conversations on topic, productive, and ensuring that discussions lead to actionable outcomes.

• Time management: Adhering to the allocated time for the session and for individual items.

• Facilitating decision-making: Facilitating the process of clarifying requirements, defining acceptance criteria, estimating effort, and making prioritization decisions.

• Documentation: Ensuring that all decisions, changes to items, estimates, and priorities are accurately captured, typically within the team's backlog management tool.

• Follow-up communication: Summarize key outcomes, action items, and communicate them to the team and relevant stakeholders after the session.

Ultimately, the individual leading the refinement process must possess strong communication, moderation, and organizational skills to steer the team towards a well-understood and actionable backlog.

Who should attend backlog grooming sessions.

These events are meant to be collaborative, so the entire cross-functional team should be represented at refinement sessions.

But at a minimum, the following people need to be involved in backlog grooming sessions:

• Facilitator. This should be someone who facilitates the session. It could be a product owner, product manager, Scrum Master, project manager, or even an Agile coach or consultant.
• Engineers or developers. These people own the narratives stored in the backlog.
• Delivery team. While the entire team plays a key role in bringing your company’s products to your customer base, if the group is too large to include everyone, you can consider inviting only members of management.
• Quality assurance representatives. These team members can share user insights related to backlog of inputs.

The key is to invite only those people who are critical to the task at hand, as too many collaborators and ideas can overwhelm the session. Additionally, be sure to have conversations with stakeholders before backlog refinement, rather than during the sessions.

Backlog refinement best practices.

While individual business needs may vary, there are some best practices you can follow to maximize the team’s time and effort. High-performing Agile teams adopt a set of best practices to ensure these sessions are consistently valuable and drive real results. These practices cover everything from preparation to defining work items and the techniques used to manage them.

Assign responsibilities.

Effective backlog refinement doesn't just happen; it begins well before the scheduled meeting time. Failure to prepare adequately is a common reason for inefficient and unproductive sessions. When all attendees invest time in preparation, the refinement meeting transforms from a passive information download session into an active, collaborative working session.

This shift enables the team to delve deeper into discussions, problem-solving, and decision-making, rather than wasting valuable meeting time on disseminating basic information. The focus moves from merely learning about items to actively refining items, which is the core purpose of the gathering.

• Product owner responsibilities: The product owner should come thoroughly prepared. This includes creating a clear agenda, identifying specific backlog items that will be the focus of the session, and gathering any necessary background information, data, or preliminary stakeholder input. They should also have a firm grasp of the overall project strategy and relevant key performance indicators to guide prioritization discussions.

• Backlog attendee responsibilities: All participants should review the agenda and any shared pre-reading materials. Team members must come prepared to discuss the value and implications of features they might advocate for, having already considered how these items align with the broader product roadmap, stakeholder priorities, and defined customer personas.

Structure a backlog clearly.

A monolithic, disorganized backlog can quickly become unwieldy and a source of confusion. High-performing teams understand the importance of structuring their backlog for clarity and manageability.

• Categorization: Instead of a single, sprawling list, it's advisable to split the backlog into logical categories. For example, teams might maintain a development backlog (for committed work), a product backlog (for upcoming features and improvements), and an insights backlog (for raw ideas, user feedback, and research findings). This separation enables the management and review of different types of items in a manner that is appropriate to the needs of the organization.
• Clear naming and labeling: Each backlog item should have a clear, concise, and descriptive name. Consistent labeling or tagging can further aid in organization and filtering.
• Defined inflow: Establish clear workflows for capturing and funneling new requests, ideas, bug reports, and other inputs into the appropriate backlog or backlog section. This ensures that incoming items are not lost and can be systematically reviewed and prioritized.

Categorizing backlogs effectively serves as a form of information architecture for the product development process. It reduces cognitive overload for the team and allows different stakeholders to concentrate on the sections most relevant to their roles.

Break down large items.

A common challenge in backlog management is dealing with significant, complex features or requirements, often referred to as epics. A key best practice in refinement is to break these epics down into smaller, more manageable user stories that can be completed within a single sprint.

• Benefits of smaller stories: Smaller stories are less daunting for the team, easier to understand and estimate accurately, allow for more frequent delivery of incremental value, and facilitate faster feedback loops from users and stakeholders.
• Techniques for breakdown: This can involve splitting epics by user roles, process steps, business rules, or technical layers. User story mapping is a visual technique that can be particularly helpful in identifying the constituent parts of a larger user journey and breaking it down into actionable stories.

The act of breaking down epics is not merely an exercise in making work appear smaller; it is a critical step in de-risking development and enabling actual iterative progress. Each smaller story represents a testable increment in functionality.

Manage dependencies.

Few backlog items exist in complete isolation. Identifying and managing dependencies between user stories or tasks is a crucial aspect of refining the backlog.

• Impact of unmanaged dependencies: Unidentified or unmanaged dependencies are a common source of sprint disruptions, bottlenecks, and delays. A team might start work on a story only to find it's blocked by another story that hasn't been completed or even started.

• Proactive identification: During refinement, teams should actively look for dependencies. This might involve asking questions like, "does this story rely on any other work being done first?" or "will any other work be blocked if this story isn't completed?"

• Visualization: Dependencies can be visualized (e.g., on a story map, a physical board with strings, or within backlog management tools) to help the product owner sequence work logically and teams to coordinate their efforts.

Avoid common challenges.

To maximize the benefits of backlog refinement, it's essential to recognize and address the common pitfalls that can derail the process.

Challenge - Unplanned backlog sessions: One of the most frequent issues is neglecting to hold regular refinement sessions or conducting them without a clear plan or agenda. This can lead to a stale backlog and inefficient meetings.

Solution: Establish a regular, recurring cadence for refinement sessions (e.g., weekly or bi-weekly) and ensure each session has a prepared agenda with specific items targeted for discussion.

Challenge - Undefined goals and scope of user stories: Vague backlog items, lack of clear goals, or have poorly defined scope can lead to confusion, extended discussions, and difficulty in estimation.

Solution: Ensure each story has a clear purpose and value proposition. Apply the INVEST criteria to assess story quality and work towards meeting a team-defined “Definition of Ready" (DoR) before considering an item sprint-ready.

Challenge - Lack of prioritization or ignoring dependencies: An unprioritized backlog, or one where dependencies are not identified and managed, can result in teams working on low-value items or frequently encountering blockages.

Solution: Employ a consistent and transparent prioritization method. Actively identify dependencies during refinement and ensure the Product Owner sequences work accordingly.

Workfront: A solution for effective backlog grooming.

Workfront helps teams create high-quality work together with speed and efficiency. It offers highly visual collaboration tools and automation features that streamline review workflows, all within a centralized location. This ensures everyone has equal, real-time visibility into the status of a project and its constituent parts, including the backlog of items being prepared for future work.

Avoiding common pitfalls requires discipline and a commitment to the principles outlined. The adoption of suitable collaboration and project management tools, like Workfront, can further empower teams by providing the necessary infrastructure for visibility, communication, and workflow management.

To explore how Workfront can support your team's backlog grooming and overall project management needs, watch the overview video.

https://business.adobe.com/fragments/resources/cards/thank-you-collections/workfront