Fifty-nine percent of consumers will abandon a preferred brand for an unfamiliar competitor the moment an AI tool recommends it instead. That single statistic captures the risk now facing every brand competing in conversational search: the assistant sitting between a shopper and a purchase decision can make or break a brand relationship in one exchange.
To understand exactly how this shift is playing out, Adobe for Business surveyed 1,011 U.S. consumers who use large language models, including ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity, to research, compare, and choose what they buy. The findings below map how trust, discovery, and loyalty are being rebuilt around AI recommendations. To help enterprises navigate this shift, Adobe for Business examines what these changes mean for any brand aiming to maintain large language model (LLM) visibility in this new search-everywhere landscape.
Key findings summary.
- 59% of consumers will abandon their preferred brand for an unfamiliar competitor if AI recommends it.
- 83% of consumers stick with a brand they first discovered through AI, making it a long-term catalyst for brand switching.
- 61% stay with the AI-recommended brand for better value, and 60% stay for superior quality.
- 35% of consumers see incorrect AI-produced data as a shared ecosystem mistake, but when blaming a single party, 38% point to AI platforms versus 13% who blame the brand.
- 59% of consumers lose trust in a brand if AI displays incorrect information about it.
- 36% of consumers trust traditional search and AI search equally, while 27% already trust AI search summaries more than traditional search.
- 47% of website click-throughs from AI are triggered by side-by-side brand evaluations, while key feature summaries drive 42%.
- 95% of consumers use AI to research purchases under $500, making AI visibility essential for capturing high-intent commerce.
These findings show that AI is opening a new door for brands to connect with shoppers exactly when they're ready to buy. Instead of competing for the top link on a results page, marketers now have the chance to introduce their brands through helpful recommendations that consumers already trust and return to. Keeping product information accurate and easy to find is what turns a routine comparison into a lasting customer relationship.
